Blamed for a Car Accident You Didn't Cause in California?
"Can I still recover compensation if an insurance company blames me for a car accident I didn't cause or if I was partially at fault in California?"
Blamed for a Car Accident You Didn't Cause? You May Still Be Entitled to Compensation
You know what happened. The other driver cut into your lane, or ran the light while you were turning. Then their insurance company calls and says the accident was your fault, and you get nothing.
This happens to people every day, and it is often not the final word. Here is why insurers get fault wrong, how an experienced attorney can push back, and why California law may let you recover money even if you were partly to blame.
Why Insurance Companies So Often Get Fault Wrong
Many crashes have no video footage and no independent witnesses. Early on, the adjuster usually has two stories to compare: yours and their own policyholder's.
Insurers often side with the person they insure. If that driver gives a false or self-serving account, the adjuster may simply accept it. With nothing but your word on the other side, the company denies the claim and blames you.
These disputes come up most often in:
- Unsafe lane changes, where each driver says the other drifted over
- Left-turn crashes at intersections, where one driver is turning left, the other is going straight from the opposite direction, and both say they had the light
Whatever the facts, the result is often the same: no offer, no payment, and medical bills that keep coming.
Why Your Word Alone Usually Isn't Enough
When you handle the claim yourself, the adjuster has little reason to look past your statement. To them, it is just one person's word against another's.
An attorney changes that. When a lawyer represents you, the insurance company knows its decision may be tested with evidence and, if needed, in court. That pressure often makes them take a second, closer look at how the crash actually happened. It can also change their position on who was at fault.
How an Attorney Can Shift the Evidence in Your Favor
1. The Vehicle's "Black Box" (Event Data Recorder)
Most modern vehicles have an Event Data Recorder (EDR). It captures data in the moments before, during, and after a crash, including:
- Speed
- Throttle position
- Braking
- Engine RPM
- Steering input
This data can change a case. It might show the other driver was speeding at impact, or that they jerked the steering wheel in a way that matches an unsafe lane change.
EDR data isn't recorded in every crash, especially lower-impact ones. Getting it out also takes a qualified expert with specialized equipment, and the vehicle must be preserved before the data is lost. That is one reason to call an attorney early.
2. Cell Phone Records
Was the other driver texting or on a call when they hit you? An attorney can subpoena phone records to find out. Proof of distraction can turn a "he said, she said" dispute into a strong liability case.
3. Written Discovery Under Oath
In a lawsuit, your attorney can send the other driver written questions about how the crash happened. They must answer under penalty of perjury. Telling a story to an adjuster is very different from swearing to it.
4. Depositions
Your attorney can also question the other driver in person, under oath, with a court reporter taking down every word. People who are not telling the truth often struggle to keep their story straight under careful questioning. Inconsistencies come out, and they can change everything.
The bottom line: a denial from the insurance company is a starting position, not a verdict. With the right evidence, an attorney can show the other driver was fully or partly at fault.
What If You Were Partly at Fault? California Still Protects You
Many people think that if they were even a little to blame, they can't recover anything. In California, that is not true.
California's "Pure Comparative Negligence" Rule
California follows a system called pure comparative negligence. In its landmark decision in Li v. Yellow Cab Co., the California Supreme Court did away with the old all-or-nothing rule. It held that "in all actions for negligence resulting in injury to person or property, the contributory negligence of the person injured in person or property shall not bar recovery, but the damages awarded shall be diminished in proportion to the amount of negligence attributable to the person recovering." Li v. Yellow Cab Co., 13 Cal. 3d 804, 829 (Cal. 1975).[i]
Fittingly, that case was itself about a disputed left turn. The plaintiff was turning left across oncoming lanes when a taxi that was speeding, and had entered the intersection on a yellow light, crashed into her car. The trial court found she was also negligent and awarded her nothing. The California Supreme Court reversed that ruling.
In plain terms: your compensation goes down by your share of the fault, but it does not disappear. Because California's rule is "pure," you can recover even if you were equally or more at fault than the other driver.
How It Works: A Simple Example
Say your medical bills, lost wages, and pain and suffering add up to $100,000:
|
Your Share of Fault |
Your Recovery |
|---|---|
|
0% |
$100,000 |
|
20% |
$80,000 |
|
50% |
$50,000 |
|
70% |
$30,000 |
Every percentage point of fault matters. Moving your share from 50% to 20% means $30,000 more in your pocket. This is where a skilled attorney makes a real difference.
Don't Accept "It Was Your Fault" as the Final Answer
If an insurance company has blamed you for an accident you didn't cause, or blamed you more than you deserve, you have options. An experienced attorney can:
- Collect evidence the adjuster never looked at
- Hold the other driver accountable under oath
- Argue for a fair split of fault
- Fight for the full compensation you're owed
Time matters. Evidence like EDR data, phone records, and witness memories can disappear quickly, and legal deadlines apply. For these reasons, it is important to contact an attorney early in your case.
Christopher B. Dolan is the owner of the Dolan Law Firm. David Villarreal is an associate attorney in our downtown Los Angeles office. We serve clients from the San Francisco Bay Area and California from our San Francisco, Oakland, Redondo Beach and Los Angeles offices. Email questions and topics for future articles to help@dolanlawfirm.com. Each situation is different, and this column does not constitute legal advice. We recommend consulting with an experienced trial attorney to understand your rights fully.